{"disclaimer":"This is a summary of public court records and is not legal advice. Missouri slip opinions may be modified or withdrawn; consult the official source.","party":{"slug":"shelter-mutual-insurance-company","displayName":"Shelter Mutual Insurance Company","totalCases":28},"cases":[{"caseId":"moappwd:wd85527:2024-02-20","opinionId":"306b5746-cbdb-5fc7-a0d3-d38d31d37d83","slug":"shelter-mutual-insurance-company-v-trevor-hill-leslie-hill-lanie-hill-and-d85527","caseName":"Shelter Mutual Insurance Company\nvs. \nTrevor Hill, Leslie Hill, Lanie Hill and Shelbie Alexander","caseNumber":"WD85527","court":"moappwd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District","decisionDate":"2024-02-20","year":2024,"display_summary":"Shelter Mutual Insurance Company appealed a summary judgment holding that a minor child was not a resident of her natural father's household for purposes of an insurance policy exclusion, after the child was injured on the father's property. The trial court had granted summary judgment for the respondents and denied Shelter's cross-motion. The appellate court affirmed in part and reversed in part, remanding the case for further proceedings, holding that summary judgment was improper because the ultimate factual determination of the child's residency remained in dispute, even with stipulated facts.","primaryTopic":"insurance","topicSlugs":["insurance","summary-judgment","civil-procedure","family-law"],"outcomeNorm":"unknown","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=205633","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/shelter-mutual-insurance-company-v-trevor-hill-leslie-hill-lanie-hill-and-d85527","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":36,"source":"topic","evidence":["topic: insurance","text: insurance policy","text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"family","label":"Family Law","href":"/practice-areas/family","score":32,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: family-law","topic: family-law"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/family"},{"slug":"litigation","label":"Civil Litigation","href":"/practice-areas/litigation","score":18,"source":"topic","evidence":["topic: civil-procedure","topic: summary-judgment","text: summary judgment","fallback litigation route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/litigation"}],"role":"appellant"},{"caseId":"mo:sc97511:2019-06-04","opinionId":"fc03ff1c-29b2-59e0-a56d-81deea82d418","slug":"leslie-seaton-respondent-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-appellant-c97511","caseName":"Leslie Seaton, Respondent, vs. Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Appellant.","caseNumber":"SC97511","court":"mo","courtLabel":"Supreme Court of Missouri","decisionDate":"2019-06-04","year":2019,"display_summary":"Leslie Seaton sought underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage from Shelter Mutual Insurance Company after her daughter's fatal accident. The circuit court granted summary judgment for Seaton, finding her daughter was entitled to UIM coverage under two policies. The Supreme Court of Missouri reversed, holding that the plain language of the insurance policies unambiguously excluded the daughter from UIM coverage as she did not meet the definition of an \"insured\" or \"relative\" and the policies were not internally inconsistent.","primaryTopic":"insurance","topicSlugs":["insurance","contracts","summary-judgment","appellate-procedure"],"outcomeNorm":"mixed","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=140913","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/leslie-seaton-respondent-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-appellant-c97511","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":40,"source":"topic","evidence":["topic: insurance","text: underinsured","text: coverage","text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance coverage dispute signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":20,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"},{"slug":"corporate","label":"Corporate Law","href":"/practice-areas/corporate","score":12,"source":"topic","evidence":["topic: contracts"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/corporate"}],"role":"appellant"},{"caseId":"moappd:ed105895:2018-09-11","opinionId":"5d0caa24-1678-508d-acbc-1f6f3c157e01","slug":"leslie-seaton-respondent-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-appellant-105895","caseName":"Leslie Seaton, Respondent, v. Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Appellant.","caseNumber":"ED105895","court":"moappd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District","decisionDate":"2018-09-11","year":2018,"display_summary":"Leslie Seaton's daughter was killed in an accident, and Seaton sought underinsured motorist coverage from Shelter Mutual Insurance Company under three endorsements to her auto policies. Shelter denied coverage under two policies, leading Seaton to file a declaratory judgment action. The trial court granted summary judgment for Seaton, finding she was entitled to coverage. The appellate court affirmed, holding that an ambiguity existed between the policy's definition of \"relative\" and the underinsured motorist endorsement, which must be construed in favor of the insured.","primaryTopic":"insurance","topicSlugs":["insurance","contracts","summary-judgment","appellate-procedure"],"outcomeNorm":"affirmed","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=130296","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/leslie-seaton-respondent-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-appellant-105895","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":40,"source":"topic","evidence":["topic: insurance","text: underinsured","text: coverage","text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance coverage dispute signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":20,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"},{"slug":"corporate","label":"Corporate Law","href":"/practice-areas/corporate","score":12,"source":"topic","evidence":["topic: contracts"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/corporate"}],"role":"appellant"},{"caseId":"mo:sc95844:2017-03-14","opinionId":"25f1eca3-ed67-53a3-9dc5-fa080141a878","slug":"jeffrey-d-swadley-chelsea-s-swadley-and-brooke-l-swadley-respondents-v-sh-c95844","caseName":"Jeffrey D. Swadley, Chelsea S. Swadley, and Brooke L. Swadley, Respondents, vs. Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Appellant.","caseNumber":"SC95844","court":"mo","courtLabel":"Supreme Court of Missouri","decisionDate":"2017-03-14","year":2017,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"mixed","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=110753","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/jeffrey-d-swadley-chelsea-s-swadley-and-brooke-l-swadley-respondents-v-sh-c95844","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"appellant"},{"caseId":"moappd:ed104654:2017-03-07","opinionId":"64370cc0-d19f-50d8-909e-55d3ba583105","slug":"corey-carter-respondent-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-appellant-104654","caseName":"Corey Carter, Respondent, vs. Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Appellant.","caseNumber":"ED104654","court":"moappd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District","decisionDate":"2017-03-07","year":2017,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"unknown","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=110503","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/corey-carter-respondent-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-appellant-104654","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"appellant"},{"caseId":"moappwd:wd78252:2015-11-17","opinionId":"cd09cbba-fc79-545e-b6c5-235e3c81d05e","slug":"cody-warden-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-d78252","caseName":"Cody Warden\nvs.\nShelter Mutual Insurance Company","caseNumber":"WD78252","court":"moappwd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District","decisionDate":"2015-11-17","year":2015,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"affirmed","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=96913","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/cody-warden-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-d78252","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"respondent"},{"caseId":"mo:sc93904:2014-07-29","opinionId":"6593d703-a472-528b-b9c4-25b653c17b55","slug":"rebecca-floyd-tunnell-et-al-appellants-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-c93904","caseName":"Rebecca Floyd-Tunnell, et al., Appellants vs. Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Respondent.","caseNumber":"SC93904","court":"mo","courtLabel":"Supreme Court of Missouri","decisionDate":"2014-07-29","year":2014,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"unknown","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=76213","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/rebecca-floyd-tunnell-et-al-appellants-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-c93904","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"respondent"},{"caseId":"moappwd:wd76401:2013-12-24","opinionId":"358ce2ab-d4fd-5490-b6c9-e6331f250cbe","slug":"shelter-mutual-insurance-company-v-jay-macvittie-and-debra-macvittie-d76401","caseName":"Shelter Mutual Insurance Company vs. Jay Macvittie and Debra Macvittie","caseNumber":"WD76401","court":"moappwd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District","decisionDate":"2013-12-24","year":2013,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"mixed","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=68575","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/shelter-mutual-insurance-company-v-jay-macvittie-and-debra-macvittie-d76401","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"appellant"},{"caseId":"mo:sc92520:2013-05-28","opinionId":"2b2dfc00-a0a0-51e6-a52c-f3a7a305ed14","slug":"charzetta-steele-appellant-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respondent-c92520","caseName":"Charzetta Steele, Appellant vs. Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Respondent.","caseNumber":"SC92520","court":"mo","courtLabel":"Supreme Court of Missouri","decisionDate":"2013-05-28","year":2013,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"affirmed","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=62254","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/charzetta-steele-appellant-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respondent-c92520","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"respondent"},{"caseId":"moappwd:wd72991:2011-11-08","opinionId":"27112378-831a-502a-8fd8-36fe21921e41","slug":"cynthia-wasson-and-kenneth-wasson-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-d72991","caseName":"Cynthia Wasson and Kenneth Wasson vs. Shelter Mutual Insurance Company","caseNumber":"WD72991","court":"moappwd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District","decisionDate":"2011-11-08","year":2011,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"mixed","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=50491","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/cynthia-wasson-and-kenneth-wasson-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-d72991","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"respondent"},{"caseId":"mo:sc90139:2009-12-08","opinionId":"b5148d7d-7d79-51bf-b637-f9bc7e01fe35","slug":"jason-l-rice-respondent-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-appellant-c90139","caseName":"Jason L. Rice, Respondent v. Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Appellant","caseNumber":"SC90139","court":"mo","courtLabel":"Supreme Court of Missouri","decisionDate":"2009-12-08","year":2009,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"affirmed","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=35936","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/jason-l-rice-respondent-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-appellant-c90139","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"appellant"},{"caseId":"moappwd:wd69411:2009-03-10","opinionId":"b4a9d812-9eea-559e-a948-09d60462c7aa","slug":"jason-l-rice-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-d69411","caseName":"Jason L. Rice vs. Shelter Mutual Insurance Company","caseNumber":"WD69411","court":"moappwd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District","decisionDate":"2009-03-10","year":2009,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"unknown","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=30013","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/jason-l-rice-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-d69411","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"respondent"},{"caseId":"moappwd:wd68698:2008-11-12","opinionId":"e9db701f-96e6-5892-a436-83929a28f591","slug":"sherry-k-byers-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-d68698","caseName":"Sherry K. Byers vs. Shelter Mutual Insurance Company","caseNumber":"WD68698","court":"moappwd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District","decisionDate":"2008-11-12","year":2008,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"affirmed","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=26831","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/sherry-k-byers-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-d68698","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":38,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: insurance","text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":1,"source":"text","evidence":["related personal-injury route for specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"respondent"},{"caseId":"moappwd:wd75725:undated","opinionId":"52da1309-1b23-553b-bdef-8c5ce7d4adc4","slug":"rebecca-floyd-tunnell-et-al-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-d75725","caseName":"Rebecca Floyd-Tunnell, et al vs. Shelter Mutual Insurance Company","caseNumber":"WD75725","court":"moappwd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District","decisionDate":null,"year":2013,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"mixed","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=67413","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/rebecca-floyd-tunnell-et-al-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-d75725","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"respondent"},{"caseId":"moappd:ed87606:undated","opinionId":"00c6d48e-4b51-50f0-9574-5c91aaa96312","slug":"shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respondent-v-american-family-mutual-insu-d87606","caseName":"Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Respondent v. American Family Mutual Insurance Company, Appellant.","caseNumber":"ED87606","court":"moappd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District","decisionDate":null,"year":2006,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"affirmed","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=15661","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respondent-v-american-family-mutual-insu-d87606","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":42,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: insurance","text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":1,"source":"text","evidence":["related personal-injury route for specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"respondent"},{"caseId":"moappwd:wd87167:undated","opinionId":"a122296c-6b6c-540d-87bd-c8668c363acf","slug":"linda-mccarty-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-d87167","caseName":"Linda McCarty\nvs.\nShelter Mutual Insurance Company","caseNumber":"WD87167","court":"moappwd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District","decisionDate":null,"year":2024,"display_summary":"Linda McCarty sued Shelter Mutual Insurance Company for underinsured motorist (UIM) benefits after her son was killed in a car accident and she settled with the tortfeasor for $35,000. McCarty sought the full $50,000 UIM limit, while Shelter argued it was entitled to a $35,000 set-off, making the payable amount $15,000. The circuit court granted summary judgment for McCarty, finding the policy ambiguous. The appellate court reversed, holding that the policy unambiguously allowed Shelter to set off the tortfeasor's payment from the UIM limit.","primaryTopic":"insurance","topicSlugs":["insurance","summary-judgment","contracts","appellate-procedure","standard-of-review"],"outcomeNorm":"mixed","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=215254","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/linda-mccarty-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-d87167","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":36,"source":"topic","evidence":["topic: insurance","text: underinsured","text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance coverage dispute signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":20,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"},{"slug":"corporate","label":"Corporate Law","href":"/practice-areas/corporate","score":12,"source":"topic","evidence":["topic: contracts"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/corporate"}],"role":"respondent"},{"caseId":"mo:sc84617:undated","opinionId":"881fd49c-2202-5d27-a9ad-ea55ff44ebd3","slug":"shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respondent-v-director-of-revenue-appella-c84617","caseName":"Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Respondent, v. Director of Revenue, Appellant.","caseNumber":"SC84617","court":"mo","courtLabel":"Supreme Court of Missouri","decisionDate":null,"year":2003,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"unknown","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=25558","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respondent-v-director-of-revenue-appella-c84617","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"respondent"},{"caseId":"mo:sc88003:undated","opinionId":"3f049d64-c87c-5a70-a46a-f2c2b9a11b30","slug":"mark-barron-shauna-barron-kennadi-barron-christy-barron-cameron-smith-bar-c88003","caseName":"Mark Barron, Shauna Barron, Kennadi Barron, Christy Barron, Cameron Smith-Barron and Richard Allen, Respondents, v. Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Appellant.","caseNumber":"SC88003","court":"mo","courtLabel":"Supreme Court of Missouri","decisionDate":null,"year":2007,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"unknown","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=26537","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/mark-barron-shauna-barron-kennadi-barron-christy-barron-cameron-smith-bar-c88003","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"appellant"},{"caseId":"moappd:ed83118:undated","opinionId":"4e7e54ec-f9df-535c-ab2d-9bc9b32016f8","slug":"keith-anderson-appellant-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respondent-d83118","caseName":"Keith Anderson, Appellant v. Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Respondent","caseNumber":"ED83118","court":"moappd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District","decisionDate":null,"year":2004,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"affirmed","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=14502","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/keith-anderson-appellant-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respondent-d83118","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"respondent"},{"caseId":"moappwd:wd58888:undated","opinionId":"c851c18c-2d98-5b43-9f4b-1c00b53cc38b","slug":"shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respondent-v-raymond-and-dorothy-see-sha-d58888","caseName":"Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Respondent, v. Raymond and Dorothy See, Shannon Nelson, Defendants, Robert K. Slates, a Minor by and Through his Next Friend, Tina Nave and Tina Nave, Appellants.","caseNumber":"WD58888","court":"moappwd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District","decisionDate":null,"year":2001,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"affirmed","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=19039","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respondent-v-raymond-and-dorothy-see-sha-d58888","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"respondent"},{"caseId":"moappd:ed81879:undated","opinionId":"8263a80d-9bc7-5e4a-a298-09456f0b40dd","slug":"shelter-mutual-insurance-company-appellant-v-william-marquis-dba-brakes-n-d81879","caseName":"Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Appellant, v. William Marquis d/b/a Brakes N' More, Respondent","caseNumber":"ED81879","court":"moappd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District","decisionDate":null,"year":2003,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"dismissed","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=14621","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/shelter-mutual-insurance-company-appellant-v-william-marquis-dba-brakes-n-d81879","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":38,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: insurance","text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":1,"source":"text","evidence":["related personal-injury route for specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"appellant"},{"caseId":"moappwd:wd61110:undated","opinionId":"1beb7d1e-2535-595b-a3a9-0e2744ff656e","slug":"shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respondent-v-chad-a-vulgamott-appellant-d61110","caseName":"Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Respondent, v. Chad A. Vulgamott, Appellant, and Hubert Borgelt, Jeane Borgelt, and Brent A. Perry, Defendants.","caseNumber":"WD61110","court":"moappwd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District","decisionDate":null,"year":2003,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"unknown","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=20287","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respondent-v-chad-a-vulgamott-appellant-d61110","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"respondent"},{"caseId":"moappwd:wd64135:undated","opinionId":"14a406ce-dae4-5377-b6df-9a9a2a80dcf8","slug":"chastity-vega-respondent-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-appellant-d64135","caseName":"Chastity Vega, Respondent, v. Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Appellant.","caseNumber":"WD64135","court":"moappwd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District","decisionDate":null,"year":2005,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"unknown","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=20941","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/chastity-vega-respondent-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-appellant-d64135","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"appellant"},{"caseId":"moappwd:wd65518:undated","opinionId":"3f7068d4-ffde-5cbe-8212-e4870da2d1a0","slug":"andrew-d-waldrop-appellant-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respondent-d65518","caseName":"Andrew D. Waldrop, Appellant v. Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Respondent","caseNumber":"WD65518","court":"moappwd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District","decisionDate":null,"year":2006,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"unknown","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=21051","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/andrew-d-waldrop-appellant-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respondent-d65518","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"respondent"},{"caseId":"moappwd:wd65618:undated","opinionId":"25507e59-3e03-55a9-ac28-fcfc7d629f2d","slug":"shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respondent-v-glen-eugene-ballew-diana-ro-d65618","caseName":"Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Respondent, v. Glen Eugene Ballew, Diana Rose Ballew, Christopher Robles and Georgetta Robles, Appellants.","caseNumber":"WD65618","court":"moappwd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District","decisionDate":null,"year":2006,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"unknown","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=21128","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respondent-v-glen-eugene-ballew-diana-ro-d65618","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"respondent"},{"caseId":"moappwd:wd65947:undated","opinionId":"344e04a5-f765-5f4d-a10d-5cb6fef5b9f9","slug":"mark-barron-shauna-barron-kennadi-barron-christy-barron-cameron-smith-bar-d65947","caseName":"Mark Barron, Shauna Barron, Kennadi Barron, Christy Barron, Cameron Smith-Barron, and Richard Allen, Respondents v. Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Appellant.","caseNumber":"WD65947","court":"moappwd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District","decisionDate":null,"year":2007,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"unknown","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=21492","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/mark-barron-shauna-barron-kennadi-barron-christy-barron-cameron-smith-bar-d65947","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"appellant"},{"caseId":"moappwd:wd65963:undated","opinionId":"098363c3-50ca-5dc2-97b2-e3279d366650","slug":"verdell-porter-et-al-appellants-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respon-d65963","caseName":"Verdell Porter, et al., Appellants v. Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Respondent.","caseNumber":"WD65963","court":"moappwd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District","decisionDate":null,"year":2007,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"affirmed","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=21546","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/verdell-porter-et-al-appellants-v-shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respon-d65963","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":38,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: insurance","text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":1,"source":"text","evidence":["related personal-injury route for specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"respondent"},{"caseId":"moappwd:wd68049:undated","opinionId":"26389266-e4c4-5d24-b59d-35b796f4fdfa","slug":"shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respondent-v-dustin-sage-et-al-defendant-d68049","caseName":"Shelter Mutual Insurance Company, Respondent v. Dustin Sage, et al., Defendants, Everett and Mary Carter, Appellants.","caseNumber":"WD68049","court":"moappwd","courtLabel":"Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District","decisionDate":null,"year":2008,"display_summary":null,"primaryTopic":null,"topicSlugs":[],"outcomeNorm":"unknown","officialSourceUrl":"https://www.courts.mo.gov/file.jsp?id=21937","detailUrl":"https://ott.law/missouri-courts/opinions/shelter-mutual-insurance-company-respondent-v-dustin-sage-et-al-defendant-d68049","relatedPracticeAreas":[{"slug":"insurance-bad-faith","label":"Insurance Bad Faith","href":"/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith","score":18,"source":"text","evidence":["text: mutual insurance company","text: insurance company","text: insurance carrier party signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/insurance-bad-faith"},{"slug":"personal-injury","label":"Personal Injury","href":"/practice-areas/personal-injury","score":17,"source":"tag","evidence":["tag: personal-injury","fallback personal-injury route behind specific injury signal"],"url":"https://ott.law/practice-areas/personal-injury"}],"role":"respondent"}]}