Larry Calvert v. Noranda Aluminum Incorporated
Decision date: February 26, 20142 pages
Summary
The Missouri Court of Appeals affirmed in part and reversed and remanded the Commission's award, directing recalculation of Second Injury Fund benefits to exclude preexisting thumb disability and scarring. The Commission recalculated benefits and awarded the Second Injury Fund liability of $10,333.41 in permanent partial disability benefits based on 297.75 weeks of combined preexisting and primary injury disabilities.
Caption
| FINAL AWARD ALLOWING COMPENSATION (After Mandate from the Missouri Court of Appeals for the Southern District) | |
| Employee: | Larry D. Calvert |
| Employer: | Noranda Aluminum Incorporated |
| Insurer: | Self-Insured |
| Additional Party: | Treasurer of Missouri as Custodian of Second Injury Fund |
| On November 27, 2013, the Missouri Court of Appeals, Southern District, issued an opinion affirming in part and reversing and remanding in part the December 8, 2011, award and decision of the Labor and Industrial Relations Commission (Commission). Larry D. Calvert v. Treasurer of the State of Missouri, Custodian of Second Injury Fund, SD31751 & SD31807 (November 27, 2013). By mandate dated February 5, 2014, the Court confirmed its decision to affirm in part and to reverse and remand in part the Commission’s award and remanded this matter to the Commission with directions to recalculate the benefits due employee from the Second Injury Fund to exclude preexisting disability to employee’s thumb and any scarring.We note that the Court left undisturbed our factual findings with respect to the nature and extent of employee’s permanent partial disability referable to his preexisting conditions of ill-being and to the primary injury. Excluding, per the Court’s mandate, the preexisting disability to employee’s thumb and any scarring, our findings referable to employee’s other conditions were (and continue to be) as follows. | |
| Preexisting conditions of ill-being At the time of the primary injury, employee suffered a 22% permanent partial disability of the body as a whole referable to his neck, 15% permanent partial disability of the body as a whole referable to his back, 15% permanent partial disability of the left knee, and a 5% permanent partial disability of his right knee.Applying § 287.190 RSMo to convert employee’s preexisting disabilities into weeks of compensation yields the following results: 88 weeks for the neck, 60 weeks for the back, 24 weeks for the left knee, and 8 weeks for the right knee. The sum equals 180 weeks. | |
| The primary injury As a result of the primary injury, employee suffered the following permanent partially disabling conditions: 15% of the right wrist, 15% of the left elbow, 7.5% of the body as a whole referable to the lumbar spine, and 7.5% of the body as a whole referable to the cervical spine. Converting employee’s permanent partial disability resulting from the primary injury into weeks of compensation yields the following results: 26.25 weeks for the right wrist, 31.5 |
| Injury No.: 03-077312 |
| Employee: Larry D. Calvert |
| weeks for the left elbow, 30 weeks for the lumbar spine, and 30 weeks for the cervical spine. The sum is 117.75 weeks.Pursuant to the Court’s mandate, we have calculated 180 weeks of preexisting permanent partial disability and 117.75 weeks of permanent partial disability referable to the primary injury. The sum of these amounts is 297.75 weeks. Applying the 10% synergy factor, the result is 29.775 weeks.We conclude that the Second Injury Fund is liable for 29.775 weeks of permanent partial disability benefits. The stipulated rate of compensation for permanent partial disability benefits is 347.05. The Second Injury Fund is liable to employee for 10,333.41 in permanent partial disability benefits. |
| AwardPursuant to the Court’s mandate, the Second Injury Fund is liable to employee for $10,333.41 in permanent partial disability benefits.Any past due compensation shall bear interest as provided by law.Given at Jefferson City, State of Missouri, this 26th day of February 2014.LABOR AND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION |
| John J. Larsen, Jr., Chairman |
| James G. Avery, Jr., Member |
| Curtis E. Chick, Jr., Member |
| Attest: |
| Secretary |
Related Decisions
Dubuc v. OTG, LLC(2019)
April 17, 2019#15-087903
The Labor and Industrial Relations Commission reversed the administrative law judge's denial of benefits and awarded permanent total disability compensation against the Second Injury Fund for an employee injured in a ladder fall on October 30, 2015. The employee's claim was based on the combination of injuries from the primary accident (left wrist, ribs, kidneys, low back) combined with preexisting disabilities.
Schenewerk v. AmeriPride Services(2018)
July 27, 2018#08-077068
The Labor and Industrial Relations Commission affirmed the administrative law judge's denial of permanent total disability benefits for Roy Schenewerk's May 29, 2008 work injury, finding that his inability to work resulted primarily from subsequent worsening of preexisting conditions rather than the compensable injury combined with those conditions. The Commission determined the employee failed to provide sufficient medical evidence evaluating his disability status as of his maximum medical improvement date of September 2, 2009.
Gonzalez v. Con-Way Truckload, Inc.(2016)
February 18, 2016#10-101736
The Commission affirmed the Administrative Law Judge's award allowing workers' compensation for multiple injuries sustained by the employee in an accident, finding that the accident was the prevailing factor causing permanent partial disability to the cervical spine, lumbar spine, right shoulder, and right hip. The Commission rejected the insurer's expert opinion denying medical causation and upheld the employee's entitlement to compensation based on competent and substantial evidence.
Scott v. Scott Excavating(2014)
June 10, 2014#08-058268
The Missouri Court of Appeals reversed the Commission's initial denial of compensation, finding the denial unsupported by competent and substantial evidence. Upon remand, the Commission issued a final award allowing compensation for the employee's work-related injuries, accounting for preexisting conditions including shoulder surgery, leg fractures from a fall, and hearing loss.
Abt v. Mississippi Lime Company(2014)
May 7, 2014
The Commission awarded permanent total disability benefits to Larry Abt from the Second Injury Fund, along with permanent partial disability benefits from his employer for injuries to his left lower extremity, ribs, and lumbar spine sustained in 2001. The award was issued in compliance with a Missouri Court of Appeals mandate requiring calculation of liability between the employer and Second Injury Fund, and included reimbursement for past medical expenses.