Missouri Court of Appeals, Southern District / Mar 4, 2024
TERRENCE TYRELL TINSLEY, JR., Appellant v. STATE OF MISSOURI, Respondent
Terrence Tyrell Tinsley, Jr. appealed the denial of his Rule 24.035 motion for post-conviction relief, arguing his plea counsel was ineffective for failing to investigate and depose a co-defendant. Tinsley had entered an Alford guilty plea to robbery and armed criminal action. The motion court denied relief, finding plea counsel's testimony credible and Tinsley's and the co-defendant's testimony not credible. The Southern District affirmed, holding that Tinsley failed to demonstrate how counsel's alleged deficiency affected the voluntariness and knowledge of his guilty plea, and that the plea hearing transcript refuted his claims.