Jonathan Raymond, Appellant, v. Division of Employment Security, Respondent.
Decision date: December 7, 2010ED95549
Parties & Roles
- Appellant
- Jonathan Raymond
- Respondent
- Division of Employment Security
Disposition
Mixed outcome
- {"type":"affirmed","scope":null}
- {"type":"dismissed","scope":null}
Slip Opinion Notice
This archive contains Missouri appellate slip opinions reproduced for research convenience, not the final official reporter version. Official source links remain authoritative where provided. Joseph Ott, Attorney 67889, Ott Law Firm - Constant Victory - Personal Injury and Litigation maintains these public legal archives to support Missouri case research and to help prospective clients connect that research to the firm's courtroom practice.
Opinion
JONATHAN RAYMOND, ) No. ED95549 ) Claimant/Appellant, ) ) vs. ) Appeal from the Labor and ) Industrial Relations Commission DIVISION OF EMPLOYMENT SECURITY, ) ) FILED: December 7, 2010 Respondent. )
Jonathan Raymond ("Claimant") has filed a notice of appeal from the Labor and Industrial Relations Commission's ("Commission") decision regarding his application for unemployment benefits. We dismiss the appeal. A deputy of the Division of Employment Security ("Division") concluded that Claimant was disqualified from receiving unemployment benefits because he left work voluntarily without good cause attributable to his work or employer. Claimant sought review with the Appeals Tribunal, which affirmed the deputy's determination. Claimant then filed an application for review with the Commission. On August 23, 2010, the Commission issued its decision affirming the Appeals Tribunal's decision. Claimant filed a notice of appeal to this Court. The Division has filed a motion to dismiss Claimant's appeal, asserting it is untimely. Claimant has not filed a response to the motion.
The unemployment statutes require a claimant to file a notice of appeal to this Court from the Commission's decision within twenty days of the decision becoming final. Section 288.210, RSMo 2000. The Commission's decision becomes final ten days after it is mailed to the parties. Section 288.200.2, RSMo 2000. Here, the Commission mailed its decision to Claimant on August 23, 2010. Therefore, the notice of appeal to this Court was due on or before September 22, 2010. Sections 288.200.2, 288.210. The secretary of the Commission certified that Claimant filed her notice of appeal on September 24, 2010, which is untimely. 1 The unemployment statutes do not provide for the late filing of the notice of appeal and do not recognize any exceptions for filing out of time. McCuin Phillips v. Clean-Tech, 34 S.W.3d 854, 855 (Mo. App. E.D. 2000). Because unemployment benefits are solely a creature of statutory provision, this Court cannot create an exception where none exists. See , Martinez v. Lea-Ed, Inc., 155 S.W.3d 809, 810 (Mo. App. E.D. 2005). The Division's motion to dismiss is granted. The appeal is dismissed.
__________________________________ ROY L. RICHTER, CHIEF JUDGE
KURT S. ODENWALD, J. and GARY M. GAERTNER, JR., J., concur
1 This certification appears to be based on the postmark on the envelope in which the notice of appeal was enclosed. The record also contains a faxed copy of a letter indicating Claimant wishes to appeal. However, this has a facsimile date stamp of September 23, 2010, which is also untimely.
2
Authorities Cited
Statutes, rules, and cases referenced in this opinion.
Statutes
- RSMo § 288.200.2cited
Section 288.200.2, RSMo
- RSMo § 288.210cited
Section 288.210, RSMo
Cases
- phillips v clean tech 34 sw3d 854cited
Phillips v. Clean-Tech, 34 S.W.3d 854
Related Opinions
Cases sharing legal topics and authorities with this opinion.
Thelma Joseph, Claimant/Appellant, v. Schnuck Markets, Inc., and Division of Employment Security, Respondents.(2002)
Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District#ED81097
William Potts, Jr., Claimant/Appellant v. Council for Extended Care of Mentally Retarded Citizens, and Division of Employment Security, Respondents.(2003)
Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District#ED82733
Nevada J. Daniels, Claimant/Appellant v. Colonial Care Center and Division of Employment Security, Respondents.(2003)
Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District#ED82614
Brenda Williams, Claimant/Appellant, v. Lutheran Senior Services, and Division of Employment Security, Respondents.(2003)
Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District#ED82349
Kelly West, Claimant/Appellant, v. Integral Properties, LLC, and Division of Employment Security, Respondents.(2003)
Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District#ED82466
Belinda Hooker, Claimant/Appellant, v. City of University City, and Division of Employment Security, Respondents.(2002)
Missouri Court of Appeals, Eastern District#ED81824